Verified Buyer Reviews
With over 1,500 verified buyer reviews on Proxibid (our earliest on record dating to 2017) and more than one million transactions conducted since 1998, every review below comes from a real buyer who completed a verified purchase through our auction platform. Together, they bear witness to our growth from a family-owned small business, through years of disciplined operation, into a nationally recognized auction house established in transparency, sustained in consistency, and confirmed in trust.
Gunslinger Auctions has been conducting live and online firearms auctions since 1998. Every rating on this page comes directly from a verified buyer who completed a real transaction — no anonymous submissions, no unverified accounts. We publish all feedback, including the critical ones, because we believe transparency is the foundation of trust in this industry.
Ratings sourced from our verified Proxibid seller profile. Last updated March 31, 2026.
Seller designations awarded by Proxibid
Meets the highest standard of service and ethics, with a strategic partnership with Proxibid.
Uses APN, the most secure payment network on Proxibid, encrypting all credit card transactions.
Recognized as a Proxibid Top Seller based on transaction volume and consistent buyer satisfaction.
Consistently describes items accurately — including any defects — and provides multiple photos per lot.
Less than 1% complaint rate across all transactions, with full compliance with Proxibid dispute resolution guidelines.
Showing 1051–1075 of 1,199 reviews
MARLIN 94 Lot 283
Customer service is lacking in my opinion. They could not locate my FFL information so we had to send it twice. Took them over 2 weeks to ship it out and when the box arrived the 100 year old rifle was wrapped with one thin layer of bubble wrap and tossed in a large box. I could literally shake it up and down in the box and feel the rifle moving 6" inside. Luckily it was not damaged, which was a surprise.
GECADO MODEL AUTO Lot 122
REMINGTON MODEL 870 Lot 161
REMINGTON MODEL 510 Lot 342
REMINGTON MODEL 24 Lot 607
Great customer service and follow up when contacted. Item was very well packaged. Only nit is it was rather slow to ship. Certainly I will buy from Gunslinger auctions again. Thanks!
WINCHESTER XTR Lot 308
I really shouldn't complain about the fees onter than shipping but they are very high but advertised that way.
COLT MODEL 1991A1 CUSTOM Lot 138
SAKO 85L Lot 38
AMT MODEL SHARPS Lot 220
NO INFO WAS SENT WITH THIS GUN!!!! MY FFL HAD TO MAKE 2 PHONE CALLS TO FIND OUT WHAT THE GUN WAS AND WHO ITS FOR AND FROM!!!!!! THEIR FFL WAS NOT INCLUDED!!!! EXTREMELY UNPROFESSIONAL FOR A GUN DEALER!!! And as always, internet premium wayyyyy too high.
DAN WESSON 6 INCH BARREL Lot 336
WINCHESTER MODEL 67 Lot 389
Firearem conditiion descriptions could be significanly improved. The firearm purchased was very old and had been referbrished. Shipping costs were exceptionally high.
SPRINGFIELD MODEL 1894 KRAG Lot 242
Rifle won at auction was a pre 1898 antique. Seller recognized this fact, but would not ship it to me. He insisted on shipping to FFL. This was an unnecessary inconvenience and expense.
WINCHESTER MODEL 1907 SELF-LOADING SEMI-AUTO RIFLE .351 WIN. CAL. Lot 256
Phoenix Arms Semi Auto Model HP22A Lot 48
This gun was supposed to be $115.00 that was my high bid and even sent a message that it jumped to $140 and was not my bid yet I still ended up paying for the Dang thing.
REMINGTON MODEL 11-48 Lot 49
took a little longer than I expected but quality was much better than I expected
WINCHESTER MODEL 1885 Lot 380
REMINGTON 572 FIELDMASTER Lot 42
REMINGTON760 Lot 25
Seller is great. Internet fees are high. My problem was with the online bidding. I tried to bid on several items and pressed the bid button as quickly as possible only to get a message that the item had sold!!! I have very fast internet 300 Mbps so I don't know where the problem with lag is. I guess I will have to go to live auction in future.
WINCHESTER MODEL 1902 SINGLE SHOT BOLT ACTION TAKEDOWN RIFLE, .22 S, L or LR CAL. Lot 594
The description stated that this was a Winchester Model 1902 in good condition. It should have said that this is a Winchester barrel bubba'd onto an unknown stock that doesn't fit right! The stock that came with this "gun" is not a Winchester stock. This is a parts gun or gunsmith "special"- not a gun in "good" condition!
RUGER M77 .270 BOLT ACTION RIFLE Lot 32
Totally screwed me on shipping, I called and questioned the $150 charge when the auction stated $90, requested one box, items were shipped in two boxes and the only reason is to try to justify the high shipping which was still higher that the actual shipping cost. The two boxes could have been taped together and still been under size and cheaper. Once my card was charged it was tough luck.
MARLIN Lot 387
Extremely POOR experience with this seller. Had to email multiple times before responding. Asked them to NOT use FedEX, please ship UPS or USPS. They used FedEX. NEVER sent a tracking number. Numerous emails not answered. Highly dissatisfied with their lack of communication and slow shipping.
RUGER GP100 .44 SPECIAL REVOLVER Lot 451
I was double charged for sales tax, the first time. The Proxibid representatives did not understand, or want to, the problem. I settled with the auction house and paid them the correct amount. Proxibid still charged me anyway, and I have sent the issue to my credit card company as a dispute. Proxibid still seems unwilling/unable to understand what they did.
WINCHESTER MODEL SUPER X 1 Lot 170
Please send shotgun to Tim VonSeggern 78732 Hwy 53 Nehalem, OR. 97131
S&W REGULATION POLICE 38 Lot 153
I participated in the online auction on Sunday 5/1 and won the lot that I was bidding on. Spent $ 2500.00 supplied all required payment and required documentation the following day Monday 5/2 and 5 days later I have still received no confirmation as to the shipment of the item purchased. Very slow in completion the transaction process on their end. will never participate in one of their auction again.