With over 1,500 verified buyer reviews on Proxibid (our earliest on record dating to 2017) and more than one million transactions conducted since 1998, every review below comes from a real buyer who completed a verified purchase through our auction platform. Together, they bear witness to our growth from a family-owned small business, through years of disciplined operation, into a nationally recognized auction house established in transparency, sustained in consistency, and confirmed in trust.
Gunslinger Auctions has been conducting live and online firearms auctions since 1998. Every rating on this page comes directly from a verified buyer who completed a real transaction — no anonymous submissions, no unverified accounts. We publish all feedback, including the critical ones, because we believe transparency is the foundation of trust in this industry.
Ratings sourced from our verified Proxibid seller profile. Last updated March 31, 2026.
Seller designations awarded by Proxibid
Meets the highest standard of service and ethics, with a strategic partnership with Proxibid.
Uses APN, the most secure payment network on Proxibid, encrypting all credit card transactions.
Recognized as a Proxibid Top Seller based on transaction volume and consistent buyer satisfaction.
Consistently describes items accurately — including any defects — and provides multiple photos per lot.
Less than 1% complaint rate across all transactions, with full compliance with Proxibid dispute resolution guidelines.
Showing 1026–1050 of 1,199 reviews
Auctioneer needs to watch his mouth during a 'LIVE broadcast. It is very unprofessional to stop and argue with buyers in the audience and to say, "What the F--K is going on when you are live. Auction company needs to do better research on firearms they are selling. The gun I purchased was listed as a S&W model 19 and is actually a pre-model 27!!!
Shipped by mistake this Antique pre-1898 to an FFL who charged me transfer fee.
Gun was supposed to be 12 gauge but wasn't.
Excessive shipping and add on fees. Count me out in the future.
The pictures did not do this rifle justice. Absolutely beautiful rifle considering it is 75 years old. Thanks.
Shipping was more than any other gun that I have purchased on line Nice gun scope was pretty beat up
Great find if the original 1860 replica.
This rifle has a very noticeable crack in the butt stock behind the receiver tang, which you absolutely should have disclosed in your auction listing. This goes beyond buyer beware - things like cracks are something that sellers have a duty to disclose. Please take more time and be more careful when drafting future listings.
Originally advertized as a 44 mag. It turns out this was a 357. I guess I don't mind.
Very happy with the rifle overall. Sellers Internet sales fee of 20% is a bit excessive, on top of shipping and FFL transfer fees. A charge of 15% would be more in line with other auction services. Shipping charges of $65 seems high, especially I had another rifle shipped in from another auction the same week, similar miles away and that one only cost me $40. only
Took a long time for delivery
Listing photos need to be larger for more accurate viewing of items. Had the seller posted a view of the hammer held back, I would have seen that the firing pin is missing, I would not have bid on the firearm. However, I have contacted the seller and we've come to an understanding on this item.
B-