S&W MODEL 58 DOUBLE ACTION REVOLVER .41 MAG Lot 319
★★★★☆
10th_Mountain
Buyer Feedback
Verified Buyer Reviews
With over 1,500 verified buyer reviews on Proxibid (our earliest on record dating to 2017) and more than one million transactions conducted since 1998, every review below comes from a real buyer who completed a verified purchase through our auction platform. Together, they bear witness to our growth from a family-owned small business, through years of disciplined operation, into a nationally recognized auction house established in transparency, sustained in consistency, and confirmed in trust.
4
★★★★☆
1,199 verified transactions
Gunslinger Auctions has been conducting live and online firearms auctions since 1998. Every rating on this page comes directly from a verified buyer who completed a real transaction — no anonymous submissions, no unverified accounts. We publish all feedback, including the critical ones, because we believe transparency is the foundation of trust in this industry.
Ratings sourced from our verified Proxibid seller profile. Last updated March 31, 2026.
Seller designations awarded by Proxibid
✓
Preferred Seller
Meets the highest standard of service and ethics, with a strategic partnership with Proxibid.
🔒
APN Secured
Uses APN, the most secure payment network on Proxibid, encrypting all credit card transactions.
⭐
Top Seller
Recognized as a Proxibid Top Seller based on transaction volume and consistent buyer satisfaction.
📷
Catalog Seller
Consistently describes items accurately — including any defects — and provides multiple photos per lot.
🏆
Super Seller
Less than 1% complaint rate across all transactions, with full compliance with Proxibid dispute resolution guidelines.
Showing 726–750 of 1,199 reviews
HASTON MODEL SINGLE SHOT Lot 279
★★★★☆
pilot253
It arrived timely and was probably a little better that was described and what the photos showed.
ANTIQUE BABY POCKET REVOLVER IN 22 CAL ENGRAVED Lot 288
★★★★☆
unclebill1
WINCHESTER 1873 Lot 267
★★★★☆
huntlp1948
Excellet Seller. Would not hesitate to recommend them to other Bidders. Its hard to discribe a firearm in a few words. I think it was a well run Auction and I will continue to bid on Gunslinger Auctions. There people at the store are very polite and professional. I am very happy with thier Auction results.
WINCHESTER MODEL M1 CARBINE Lot 256
★★★★☆
jsdr011
Hardly any parts on 'this really fine Winchester' were actually Winchester parts!
COLT MODEL 1903 POCKET HAMMERLESS Lot 57
★★★★☆
pilot253
Excellent transaction. Any slowdowns in the shipping were strictly my fault. Will deal with again.
REMINGTON MODEL 11 Lot 54
★★★★☆
RogueTS1
Very professional seller with great communication and customer service. They made the transaction super smooth and easy. Super fast shipping.
REMINGTON MODEL 81 Lot 35
★★★★☆
guitounet
REMINGTON MODEL 700 ADL Lot 239
★★★★☆
dkrakoski
dleivered in timely fashion, better than expected
WINCHESTER 70 .243 BOLT ACTION RIFLE Lot 337
★★★★☆
Woitafarms
Okay
SMITH & WESSON MODEL 1 REVOLVER Lot 504
★★★★☆
juhala6
Great little gun and very friendly and helpful customer service.
RUGER M77 MK II Lot 221
★★★★☆
tobarethese
thank you AAAAAA++++++++
ITALIAN BLACK POWDER 31 CAL POCKET REVOLVER Lot 274
★★★★☆
meanerkitty
Good service.
ARMI SAN MARCO NEW DAKOTA MODEL SAA REVOLVER .357 MAGNUM CAL. Lot 493
★★★★☆
cross151
ITALIAN-MADE TO ARMI SAN MARCO COPY OF A WALKER REVOLVER w/HOLSTER Lot 182
★★★★☆
bigskybound
As described. Well packed.
ONE BEAUTIFUL BLUE WITH SPRINKLED GOLD ITALIAN GLASS BEAD NECKLACE, DIAMETER 11MM AND LENGTH 18" Lot 430A
★★★★☆
hopzip
excellent customer service
Vintage Colt Grips Lot 70
★★★★☆
wiskerchew
L.C. SMITH IDEAL GRADE Lot 208
★★★★☆
bk5247
Arisaka 99 Lot 72
★★★★☆
Gpd823
item as described
DETONICS MODEL COMBAT MASTER Lot 335
★★★★☆
MommaWookie
Good Folks At Gunslingers, great communications, could use more descriptions on their items. Fast Shippers
REMINGTON MODEL 512 Lot 250
★★★★☆
Jeus1
Spanish Model 1915 Bolt Action Rifle Lot 647
★★★★☆
dosmouser
Item as pictured and described. Shipping about $20 more than past experience but cost stated up front. Good transaction and would do business with again.
ITHACA FIELD Lot 97
★★★★☆
Mhlewis
No problems, very prompt service. I would not hesitate to bid again or recommend this auction house in the future. Thanks again.
CIMARRON MODEL 1873 Lot 7
★★★★☆
Taximanslp
A couple defects that should've been listed. Other than that a fairly simple process. Not exactly speedy though
HOWA 1500 Lot 36
★★★★☆
Captdano
I feel 18% is very high considering the volume of guns they move. Don't get me wrong I am very pleased with the rifle and I feel I got a good price on it $ 450 but after 18% buyers fee , state tax and shipping the gun ended up costing $610.