Always Accepting Consignments

Consign With Us →
Buyer Feedback

Verified Buyer Reviews

With over 1,500 verified buyer reviews on Proxibid (our earliest on record dating to 2017) and more than one million transactions conducted since 1998, every review below comes from a real buyer who completed a verified purchase through our auction platform. Together, they bear witness to our growth from a family-owned small business, through years of disciplined operation, into a nationally recognized auction house established in transparency, sustained in consistency, and confirmed in trust.

4
★★★★☆
1,199 verified transactions

Gunslinger Auctions has been conducting live and online firearms auctions since 1998. Every rating on this page comes directly from a verified buyer who completed a real transaction — no anonymous submissions, no unverified accounts. We publish all feedback, including the critical ones, because we believe transparency is the foundation of trust in this industry.

Ratings sourced from our verified Proxibid seller profile. Last updated March 31, 2026.

Seller designations awarded by Proxibid

Preferred Seller

Meets the highest standard of service and ethics, with a strategic partnership with Proxibid.

🔒 APN Secured

Uses APN, the most secure payment network on Proxibid, encrypting all credit card transactions.

Top Seller

Recognized as a Proxibid Top Seller based on transaction volume and consistent buyer satisfaction.

📷 Catalog Seller

Consistently describes items accurately — including any defects — and provides multiple photos per lot.

🏆 Super Seller

Less than 1% complaint rate across all transactions, with full compliance with Proxibid dispute resolution guidelines.

Showing 776–800 of 1,199 reviews

NIKKO MODEL 5000 Lot 229

★★★★☆
tomasquatro
Shipping Duration
★★★★☆
Shipping Price
★★★★☆
Item Description
★★★★★
Seller Fees
★★★★☆
Customer Service
★★★★☆
Fall Firearms Auction

WALTHER MODEL P22 Lot 93

★★★★☆
62papabear13
Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Item Description
★★★★★
Seller Fees
★★★☆☆
Customer Service
★★★★★
Spring Firearm Auction

NORTH AMERICAN ARMS MODEL 22M Lot 349

★★★★☆
jmorr84s

Very friendly.

Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Shipping Price
★★★★☆
Item Description
★★★★★
Seller Fees
★★★☆☆
Customer Service
★★★★☆
Winter Gun Auction

UNDERWOOD MODEL M1 CARBINE Lot 282

★★★★☆
jsdr011

Serial number off by a million!

Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Shipping Price
★★★★★
Item Description
★★★☆☆
Seller Fees
★★★★☆
Spring Firearm Auction

TRAP DOOR SPRINGFIELD BARREL & BOLT Lot 76

★★★★☆
bish3

Very nice item, better then advertised.

Shipping Duration
★★★★☆
Shipping Price
★★★★☆
Item Description
★★★★★
Seller Fees
★★★☆☆
Customer Service
★★★★☆
Winter Firearm Auction

HOME MADE TYPE BULLET MOLD. APPROX 30 CAL Lot 96

★★★★☆
sludge1949
Shipping Duration
★★★★☆
Shipping Price
★★★☆☆
Item Description
★★★★★
Seller Fees
★★★☆☆
Customer Service
★★★★★
Christmas Accessory Auction

ENFIELD MODEL NO. 1 Lot 21

★★★★☆
jake1923

A+

Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Shipping Price
★★★★☆
Item Description
★★★★★
Seller Fees
★★★★☆
Customer Service
★★★★★
May 30th, 2020 Spring Firearms Auction

CZ 452 Lot 51

★★★★☆
sldit
Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Shipping Price
★★★★★
Item Description
★★★★★
Seller Fees
★★★★☆
Customer Service
★★★★★
Firearm Auction

BROWNING MODEL LIGHTNING Lot 374

★★★★☆
sampbill

Beautiful gun in better condition than expected. I would rate this a quality seller.

Shipping Duration
★★★★☆
Shipping Price
★★★★☆
Item Description
★★★★★
Seller Fees
★★★☆☆
Winter Firearms Auction

SMITH & WESSON 1902 Lot 395

★★★★☆
jmace57

Item was as described. Shipped quickly.

Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Shipping Price
★★★★★
Item Description
★★★★☆
Seller Fees
★★★★☆
Customer Service
★★★★☆
Firearm Auction

Browning Model BDA Semi Auto Lot 46

★★★★☆
wadeosborne

I don't give 5 stars for premiums over 15%. Also, the description should have mentioned the added casing bases on the grip in lieu of the browning medallions.

Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Shipping Price
★★★★☆
Item Description
★★★★☆
Seller Fees
★★★★☆
Spring Auction

SPANISH MODEL M1916 Lot 321

★★★★☆
Waitaminuteman
Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Shipping Price
★★★☆☆
Item Description
★★★★☆
Seller Fees
★★★☆☆
Customer Service
★★★★★
September 25th, 2021 Fall Firearms Auction

J. STEVENS SINGLE SHOT TOP BREAK SHOTGUN 20 GAUGE 28" BBL. Lot 10

★★★★☆
Amosmiller
Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Shipping Price
★★★★☆
Item Description
★★★★★
Seller Fees
★★★☆☆
Customer Service
★★★★★
February 1st Antiques & Firearms Auction

GLENFIELD MODEL 25 BOLT ACTION RIFLE .22 S, L or LR CAL. w/ SCOPE Lot 554

★★★★☆
jmh48

good to work with will do biz with again

Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Shipping Price
★★★★★
Item Description
★★★★★
Seller Fees
★★★★☆
Customer Service
★★★★★
Firearms Auction

SPRINGFIELD MODEL 1873 Lot 55

★★★★☆
Chriskob
Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Shipping Price
★★★☆☆
Item Description
★★★★☆
Seller Fees
★★★☆☆
Customer Service
★★★★★
October 1st, Fall Firearms Auction

WINCHESTER 88 Lot 43

★★★★☆
redstaff
Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Shipping Price
★★★★☆
Item Description
★★★★★
Seller Fees
★★☆☆☆
Customer Service
★★★★★
2015 New Year Firearm Auction

BERTHIER-MANNLICHER MODEL 1890 CAVALRY CARBINE Lot 389

★★★★☆
guitounet
Shipping Duration
★★★★☆
Shipping Price
★★★★☆
Item Description
★★★★☆
Seller Fees
★★★★☆
Customer Service
★★★★☆
Winter Gun Auction

SMITH & WESSON MODEL M&P SHEILD EZ Lot 263

★★★★☆
Lucy3422

Jimmy helped me with my DROS and I was finished in 5-10 minutes max its never been easier; I don't mind the fees with service like that!

Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Item Description
★★★★★
Seller Fees
★★★★☆
Customer Service
★★★★★
Spring Firearms Auction

FOUR BARRELED RECEIVERS: BSA, STEVENS, CAI, NAVY ARMS Lot 694

★★★★☆
bigskybound

As described.

Shipping Duration
★★★★☆
Shipping Price
★★★★☆
Item Description
★★★★☆
Seller Fees
★★★★☆
Customer Service
★★★★☆
May 28th Spring Firearms Auction

MARLIN MODEL 1881 IN 45GOV'T Lot 194

★★★★☆
sampbill

Gun was as described.

Shipping Duration
★★★★☆
Shipping Price
★★★★★
Item Description
★★★★☆
Seller Fees
★★★★☆
Firearm Auction

SPANISH ASTRA MODEL 600/43 9MM SEMI-AUTO PISTOL Lot 398

★★★★☆
D0UGLAS

Astra was in much better condition than expected. Listing photos need to be larger in order to more accurately view item.

Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Item Description
★★★★★
Seller Fees
★★★☆☆
Customer Service
★★★★★
May 19th Firearms, Art & Jewelry Auction

SMITH & WESSON MODEL 19-3 Lot 178

★★★★☆
upsmsp

as described thank you

Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Shipping Price
★★★★☆
Item Description
★★★★★
Seller Fees
★★☆☆☆
Customer Service
★★★★☆
May 18th, Spring Firearms Auction

THOMPSON CENTER ARMS CHEROKEE PERCUSSION KENTUCKY RIFLE .32 CAL. Lot 43

★★★★☆
dcgunsales

Very nice item. Premium/ Shipping on the steep side.

Shipping Duration
★★★★☆
Shipping Price
★★★☆☆
Item Description
★★★★★
Seller Fees
★★★☆☆
Customer Service
★★★★★
September 22nd Firearms, Art & Jewelry Auction

UNIQUE SEMI AUTO IN 25 CAL Lot 357

★★★★☆
jreb44

All four Nazi era German daggers were as good or better than described. I am very pleased with shipment.

Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Shipping Price
★★★★☆
Item Description
★★★★★
Seller Fees
★★★★☆
Customer Service
★★★★★
Firearm Auction

WINCHESTER MODEL 12 Lot 264

★★★★☆
Kolo1003
Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Shipping Price
★★★★★
Item Description
★★★★★
Seller Fees
★★★★☆
Customer Service
★★★★★
Fall 2017 Firearm Auction