Always Accepting Consignments

Consign With Us →
Buyer Feedback

Verified Buyer Reviews

With over 1,500 verified buyer reviews on Proxibid (our earliest on record dating to 2017) and more than one million transactions conducted since 1998, every review below comes from a real buyer who completed a verified purchase through our auction platform. Together, they bear witness to our growth from a family-owned small business, through years of disciplined operation, into a nationally recognized auction house established in transparency, sustained in consistency, and confirmed in trust.

4
★★★★☆
1,199 verified transactions

Gunslinger Auctions has been conducting live and online firearms auctions since 1998. Every rating on this page comes directly from a verified buyer who completed a real transaction — no anonymous submissions, no unverified accounts. We publish all feedback, including the critical ones, because we believe transparency is the foundation of trust in this industry.

Ratings sourced from our verified Proxibid seller profile. Last updated March 31, 2026.

Seller designations awarded by Proxibid

Preferred Seller

Meets the highest standard of service and ethics, with a strategic partnership with Proxibid.

🔒 APN Secured

Uses APN, the most secure payment network on Proxibid, encrypting all credit card transactions.

Top Seller

Recognized as a Proxibid Top Seller based on transaction volume and consistent buyer satisfaction.

📷 Catalog Seller

Consistently describes items accurately — including any defects — and provides multiple photos per lot.

🏆 Super Seller

Less than 1% complaint rate across all transactions, with full compliance with Proxibid dispute resolution guidelines.

Showing 701–725 of 1,199 reviews

T/C BARREL IN 44 MAG Lot 46

★★★★☆
slkanedds

Item in excellent condition. Easily resold

Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Shipping Price
★★★☆☆
Item Description
★★★★★
Seller Fees
★★★★★
Customer Service
★★★★★
Fall Firearm Auction

CHARLES DALY MODEL 700 Lot 61

★★★★☆
Msknr

Super fast shipping. Item as described. Good experience with a professional seller. Would use Gunslinger Auctions again.

Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Shipping Price
★★★★☆
Item Description
★★★★☆
Seller Fees
★★★★☆
Customer Service
★★★★★
Winter Gun Auction

SAGINAW MODEL M1 CARBINE Lot 156

★★★★☆
jsdr011

Could have mentioned stock was marked Inland in description!

Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Shipping Price
★★★★★
Item Description
★★★☆☆
Seller Fees
★★★★☆
Spring Firearm Auction

Colt 1st Generation SAA Revolver Lot 124

★★★★☆
mcbrandon322

Very prompt shipping, my only criticism is that contact information was not included with shipment so FFL did not have any way to contact me, I had to call to verify shipping and FFL received which resulted in a two week delay. Overall I am satisfied with my purchase

Shipping Duration
★★★★☆
Shipping Price
★★★★☆
Item Description
★★★★★
Seller Fees
★★★☆☆
Customer Service
★★★★★
February 5th Fall Firearms Auction

SMITH & WESSON MODEL 329PD Lot 132

★★★★☆
Indomitable

Great revolver at a fair price. Thanks!

Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Shipping Price
★★★★☆
Item Description
★★★★☆
Seller Fees
★★★★☆
Fall Firearm Auction

RUGER MODEL NO.1 Lot 252

★★★★☆
Crawdog

I am very pleased with my experience with this seller. The item description was found to be very accurate after receiving the item. The description was very detailed, which is much appreciated, and was obviously done by a knowledgeable person. The 3 stars for seller's fees is only because I do not have prior experience with this type of auction, and the fee was somewhat of a kick. I did, however know the percentage going in, and it was my decision to make my bid, so all is good.

Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Shipping Price
★★★★★
Item Description
★★★★★
Seller Fees
★★★☆☆
Customer Service
★★★★★
Winter Gun Auction

RUGER M77 Lot 248

★★★★☆
campbigp1
Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Item Description
★★★★★
Seller Fees
★★★☆☆
Customer Service
★★★★★
Winter Firearm Auction

MARLIN MODEL 1893 LEVER ACTION .38-55 CAL. AGENT-MARKED RIFLE Lot 19

★★★★☆
bigskybound

As described. Mostly.

Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Shipping Price
★★★★☆
Item Description
★★★★★
Seller Fees
★★★☆☆
Customer Service
★★★★☆
April 12th Antiques & Firearms Auction

REMINGTON MODEL 511 SCOREMASTER BOLT-ACTION RIFLE, .22 S, L or LR CAL. Lot 123

★★★★☆
peddlerray
Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Shipping Price
★★★★☆
Item Description
★★★★★
Seller Fees
★★★★☆
February 14th 2026; Valentine's Auction

RUGER MODEL MK II .22 CALIBER SEMI-AUTO PISTOL (OUT-OF-STATE-ONLY) Lot 548

★★★★☆
user_bO4KZfk
Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Shipping Price
★★★★☆
Item Description
★★★★★
Seller Fees
★★★☆☆
February 1st Antiques & Firearms Auction

Lyman 38/357 Die's Lot 24

★★★★☆
Rogerric
Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Shipping Price
★★★★☆
Item Description
★★★★★
Seller Fees
★★★☆☆
Customer Service
★★★★☆
August 2017 Gun Accessories Auction

Arisaka 99 Lot 61

★★★★☆
Gpd823

Item as described

Shipping Duration
★★★★☆
Shipping Price
★★★★★
Item Description
★★★★☆
Seller Fees
★★★☆☆
Customer Service
★★★★★
January 29, 2017 Firearm Auction

BERETTA MODEL 686 ONYX Lot 356

★★★★☆
Stevencindy

very nice

Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Shipping Price
★★★★☆
Item Description
★★★★★
Seller Fees
★★★☆☆
Customer Service
★★★★★
Fall Firearms Auction

AYA MATADOR II Lot 70

★★★★☆
remchester

Good auction!

Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Item Description
★★★★★
Seller Fees
★★★★☆
Customer Service
★★★★★
Winter Firearm Auction

REMINGTON MODEL 721 Lot 69

★★★★☆
cardinalguns
Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Shipping Price
★★★★☆
Item Description
★★★★☆
Seller Fees
★★★★☆
Customer Service
★★★★★
Winter Gun Auction

SMITH & WESSON 46 .22 SEMI-AUTOMATIC PISTOL Lot 270

★★★★☆
lpataki
Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Shipping Price
★★★★☆
Item Description
★★★★★
Seller Fees
★★★★☆
Customer Service
★★★★★
May 28th Spring Firearms Auction

PERCUSSION CARBINE Lot 304

★★★★☆
bigskybound

If only it had the box, then it would be perfect. But still rates Like New. Very nice.

Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Shipping Price
★★★★★
Item Description
★★★★★
Seller Fees
★★★★☆
Customer Service
★★★★★
February 5th, 2022 Winter Firearms Auction

SAVAGE MODEL BOLT Lot 491

★★★★☆
dobk63

Very well packed.

Shipping Duration
★★★★☆
Shipping Price
★★★☆☆
Item Description
★★★★★
Seller Fees
★★★☆☆
Customer Service
★★★★★
May 18th, Spring Firearms Auction

WINCHESTER MODEL 9422 LEVER ACTION RIFLE .22 S, L OR LR CALIBER (CIRCA 1995) Lot 303

★★★★☆
sig2020

First class people to deal with. Shipping was extremely fast. Packaging of the item was spot on. Description was phenomenal like I said first class people to deal with.

Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Shipping Price
★★★★★
Item Description
★★★★★
Seller Fees
★★★★☆
Customer Service
★★★★★
December 15th 2024 Firearms & Antiques

WINCHESTER MODEL 1892 TAKEDOWN Lot 337

★★★★☆
boilerrunner03
Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Shipping Price
★★★★☆
Item Description
★★★★☆
Seller Fees
★★★☆☆
Customer Service
★★★★★
September 25th, 2021 Fall Firearms Auction

WINCHESTER MODEL 94 Lot 42

★★★★☆
Joestubby

Gun as depicted and described. Was able to doctor the bruises in wood to improve appearance a bit. Gun is a good value. Metal is very good.

Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Shipping Price
★★★★★
Item Description
★★★★★
Seller Fees
★★★☆☆
Customer Service
★★★★★
October 1st, Fall Firearms Auction

H&K MODEL P2000 DA PISTOL 9mm CAL Lot 57

★★★★☆
user_NUp7kQs
Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Shipping Price
★★★★★
Item Description
★★★★★
Seller Fees
★★★☆☆
Customer Service
★★★★★
June 7th Antique, Military, & Modern Firearms

REMINGTON MODEL 760 GAMEMASTER SEMI-AUTO CARBINE, .30-06 CAL. Lot 151

★★★★☆
David1952vt
Shipping Duration
★★★☆☆
Shipping Price
★★★★★
Item Description
★★★★★
Seller Fees
★★★★★
Customer Service
★★★★★
Firearms Auction

REMINGTON XP100 Lot 98

★★★★☆
37pont6
Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Shipping Price
★★★★☆
Item Description
★★★★☆
Seller Fees
★★★★★
Customer Service
★★★★★
Fall Firearm Auction

WINCHESTER U.S. M1 GARAND 30-06 CALIBER SEMI-AUTO RIFLE W/CANVAS SLING Lot 258

★★★★☆
mitchballard384

Yee Haw! I finally won a Winchester Garand after losing several prvious auctions. This rifle has all the original Winchester components, except the barrel. Shipping was supposed to be only $75, but turned out to be $90 Buyer's premium is the highest I have ever paid at 25% But otherwise...

Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Shipping Price
★★★☆☆
Item Description
★★★★★
Seller Fees
★★★☆☆
Customer Service
★★★★★
February 17th Firearms, Art, & Jewelry Auction