Always Accepting Consignments

Consign With Us →
Buyer Feedback

Verified Buyer Reviews

With over 1,500 verified buyer reviews on Proxibid (our earliest on record dating to 2017) and more than one million transactions conducted since 1998, every review below comes from a real buyer who completed a verified purchase through our auction platform. Together, they bear witness to our growth from a family-owned small business, through years of disciplined operation, into a nationally recognized auction house established in transparency, sustained in consistency, and confirmed in trust.

4
★★★★☆
1,199 verified transactions

Gunslinger Auctions has been conducting live and online firearms auctions since 1998. Every rating on this page comes directly from a verified buyer who completed a real transaction — no anonymous submissions, no unverified accounts. We publish all feedback, including the critical ones, because we believe transparency is the foundation of trust in this industry.

Ratings sourced from our verified Proxibid seller profile. Last updated March 31, 2026.

Seller designations awarded by Proxibid

Preferred Seller

Meets the highest standard of service and ethics, with a strategic partnership with Proxibid.

🔒 APN Secured

Uses APN, the most secure payment network on Proxibid, encrypting all credit card transactions.

Top Seller

Recognized as a Proxibid Top Seller based on transaction volume and consistent buyer satisfaction.

📷 Catalog Seller

Consistently describes items accurately — including any defects — and provides multiple photos per lot.

🏆 Super Seller

Less than 1% complaint rate across all transactions, with full compliance with Proxibid dispute resolution guidelines.

Showing 876–900 of 1,199 reviews

WALTHER MODEL PPK Lot 418

★★★★☆
roninhyde

Pistol has rust. It's not too bad, but it wasn't mentioned in the description.

Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Shipping Price
★★★★★
Item Description
★★★★☆
Seller Fees
★★★★☆
Customer Service
★★★★★
May 21st, 2022 Spring Firearms Auction

SMITH & WESSON MODEL M&P SHIELD Lot 128

★★★★☆
62papabear13
Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Item Description
★★★★☆
Seller Fees
★★★☆☆
Customer Service
★★★★☆
Winter Gun Auction

ANTIQUE LONDON-MADE Mortimer SXS 16 GAUGE SHOTGUN Lot 3

★★★★☆
Rwgray76

Item arrived safely. Well packaged. As described. Very good customer service. Will do business again. A+++++

Shipping Duration
★★★★☆
Shipping Price
★★★★☆
Item Description
★★★★★
Seller Fees
★★★★☆
Customer Service
★★★★★
February 17th Firearms, Art, & Jewelry Auction

STEVENS 311 .410 GAUGE DOUBLE BARREL SHOTGUN Lot 591

★★★★☆
bighunter
Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Shipping Price
★★☆☆☆
Item Description
★★★★★
Seller Fees
★★★☆☆
Customer Service
★★★★★
May 28th Spring Firearms Auction

H&R SELF LOADING SA IN 32 CAL Lot 358

★★★★☆
jreb44

All four daggers received in this purchase were as described and I am very satisfied with the transaction.

Shipping Duration
★★★★☆
Shipping Price
★★★☆☆
Item Description
★★★★★
Seller Fees
★★★☆☆
Customer Service
★★★★★
Firearm Auction

COLT OFFICIAL POLICE .38 SP REVOLVER Lot 600

★★★★☆
D0UGLAS

Photos need to be larger. Difficult to see many details in the small photos shown in the online listing.

Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Item Description
★★★★★
Seller Fees
★★★☆☆
Customer Service
★★★★★
May 19th Firearms, Art & Jewelry Auction

WINCHESTER 88 Lot 160

★★★★☆
Outdooreg6

Will buy again

Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Shipping Price
★★★★☆
Item Description
★★★★★
Seller Fees
★★★★☆
Customer Service
★★★★★
New Year Firearm Auction

RUGER M77 6MM REM BOLT ACTION RIFLE Lot 2

★★★★☆
dnchris70
Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Shipping Price
★★★★★
Item Description
★★★★★
Seller Fees
★★★★☆
Customer Service
★★★★★
October 8th Fall Firearms Auction

RCBS 44 Mag Die's Lot 6

★★★★☆
Little_Rocky
Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Shipping Price
★★★★☆
Item Description
★★★★★
Seller Fees
★★★★☆
Customer Service
★★★★★
August 2017 Gun Accessories Auction

INLAND M1 CARBINE Lot 51

★★★★☆
jsdr011
Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Shipping Price
★★★★☆
Item Description
★★★★☆
Seller Fees
★★★★☆
Customer Service
★★★★★
2015 New Year Firearm Auction

SHARPS NEW MODEL 1873 Lot 105A

★★★★☆
boilerrunner03
Shipping Duration
★★★★☆
Shipping Price
★★★★☆
Item Description
★★★★★
Seller Fees
★★★★☆
Customer Service
★★★★★
September 26th, 2020 Fall Firearms Auction

SPRINGFIELD MODEL 1884 ROD BAYONET Lot 404

★★★★☆
Golfer52
Shipping Duration
★★★★☆
Shipping Price
★★★★☆
Item Description
★★★★☆
Seller Fees
★★★★☆
Customer Service
★★★★☆
Winter Gun Auction

BERETTA MODEL AS12EL Lot 153

★★★★☆
jgodo
Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Shipping Price
★★★★★
Item Description
★★★★☆
Seller Fees
★★★★☆
Customer Service
★★★★★
Spring Firearm Auction

REMINGTON MODEL 1100 LW Lot 280

★★★★☆
ssmanley

As described and fast shipping.

Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Shipping Price
★★★☆☆
Item Description
★★★★★
Seller Fees
★★★☆☆
Customer Service
★★★★★
Spring Firearm Auction

PEABODY MODEL 1867 Lot 407

★★★★☆
Somogyi
Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Shipping Price
★★★★★
Item Description
★★★★☆
Seller Fees
★★★★☆
Customer Service
★★★★★
Winter Gun Auction

REMINGTON 511P .22LR BOLT ACTION RIFLE Lot 415

★★★★☆
otallman

Product description was correct, but pictures didn't show all of the damaged areas. Promptly shipped and very well packaged. Thanks!

Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Shipping Price
★★★★★
Item Description
★★★★☆
Seller Fees
★★★☆☆
Customer Service
★★★★★
December 10th Firearms, Art, and Jewelry Auction

STEYR MODEL 1886 Lot 453

★★★★☆
schutztruppe
Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Item Description
★★★★☆
Seller Fees
★★★★★
Customer Service
★★★★★
May 30th, 2020 Spring Firearms Auction

WEBLEY MODEL NO. 2 MARK I Lot 288

★★★★☆
JGUSC58

This gun is not a webley it is an enfield #2 mark 1 other than that I am very happy with the purchase.

Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Shipping Price
★★★★★
Item Description
★★★★☆
Seller Fees
★★★★★
Customer Service
★★★★★
Winter Firearms Auction

INLAND MANUFACTURING MODEL M1 CARBINE Lot 260

★★★★☆
Dedmon27
Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Shipping Price
★★★★☆
Item Description
★★★★★
Seller Fees
★★★★☆
Customer Service
★★★★★
Winter Firearms Auction

Remington Model 1861 Navy Revolver Lot 250

★★★★☆
drum4231

Received in a timely manner.

Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Shipping Price
★★★★☆
Item Description
★★★★☆
Seller Fees
★★★☆☆
Spring Auction

WINCHESTER MODEL 37 Lot 522

★★★★☆
India-14
Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Shipping Price
★★★★☆
Item Description
★★★★☆
Seller Fees
★★★★☆
Customer Service
★★★★★
September 25th, 2021 Fall Firearms Auction

REMINGTON ROLLING BLOCK .43 CF CAL RIFLE Lot 1046

★★★★☆
user_hf7jM8r

Excellent customer service when called - they were very kind and helpful and provided a good ETA.

Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Shipping Price
★★★★☆
Item Description
★★★★★
Seller Fees
★★★★★
Customer Service
★★★★★
June 8th Antique, Military, & Modern Firearms

Fancy Wood Grips for S&W 39-52-59 Lot 224

★★★☆☆
jmace57

Item was as described. Charged me $11 to ship a very small item, which they sent in a small padded envelope (costing maybe $2.50) - even AFTER I contacted them and asked them to ship it cheapest possible method as the item was only $10. Good communication other than that. They should know I won't do business with them again because of the bogus shipping charges.

Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Shipping Price
★☆☆☆☆
Item Description
★★★★★
Seller Fees
★★★☆☆
Customer Service
★★★☆☆
August 2017 Gun Accessories Auction

WINCHESTER MODEL 71 Lot 28

★★★☆☆
ironton
Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Shipping Price
★★★☆☆
Item Description
★★★☆☆
Seller Fees
★★★☆☆
Customer Service
★★★☆☆
Spring Firearm Auction

HIGH STANDARD MODEL SUPERMATIC CITATION Lot 138

★★★☆☆
jimreich
Shipping Duration
★★★★☆
Shipping Price
★★★☆☆
Item Description
★★★☆☆
Seller Fees
★★★☆☆
Customer Service
★★★★☆
Spring Firearm Auction