Always Accepting Consignments

Consign With Us →
Buyer Feedback

Verified Buyer Reviews

With over 1,500 verified buyer reviews on Proxibid (our earliest on record dating to 2017) and more than one million transactions conducted since 1998, every review below comes from a real buyer who completed a verified purchase through our auction platform. Together, they bear witness to our growth from a family-owned small business, through years of disciplined operation, into a nationally recognized auction house established in transparency, sustained in consistency, and confirmed in trust.

4
★★★★☆
1,199 verified transactions

Gunslinger Auctions has been conducting live and online firearms auctions since 1998. Every rating on this page comes directly from a verified buyer who completed a real transaction — no anonymous submissions, no unverified accounts. We publish all feedback, including the critical ones, because we believe transparency is the foundation of trust in this industry.

Ratings sourced from our verified Proxibid seller profile. Last updated March 31, 2026.

Seller designations awarded by Proxibid

Preferred Seller

Meets the highest standard of service and ethics, with a strategic partnership with Proxibid.

🔒 APN Secured

Uses APN, the most secure payment network on Proxibid, encrypting all credit card transactions.

Top Seller

Recognized as a Proxibid Top Seller based on transaction volume and consistent buyer satisfaction.

📷 Catalog Seller

Consistently describes items accurately — including any defects — and provides multiple photos per lot.

🏆 Super Seller

Less than 1% complaint rate across all transactions, with full compliance with Proxibid dispute resolution guidelines.

Showing 326–350 of 1,199 reviews

Colt 4th Gen SAA Revolver Lot 291

★★★★★
5630827
Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Shipping Price
★★★★★
Item Description
★★★★★
Seller Fees
★★★★★
Customer Service
★★★★★
February 5th Fall Firearms Auction

ASTRA 400 Lot 338

★★★★★
bassabogado

good deals, quick service in shop, accurate descriptions. A+++

Item Description
★★★★★
Seller Fees
★★★★★
Customer Service
★★★★★
Winter Firearm Auction

BROWNING MODEL 1885 Lot 65

★★★★★
gdvanous
Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Shipping Price
★★★★★
Item Description
★★★★★
Seller Fees
★★★★★
Customer Service
★★★★★
Winter Gun Auction

GLOCK MODEL 17 Lot 133

★★★★★
ldhaynes
Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Item Description
★★★★★
Seller Fees
★★★★★
Customer Service
★★★★★
Winter Gun Auction

COLT CHALLENGER Lot 344

★★★★★
tobarethese

Great Item AAAAAAAAAAAA++++++++++

Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Shipping Price
★★★★★
Item Description
★★★★★
Seller Fees
★★★★★
Customer Service
★★★★★
Firearm Auction

RUGER HAWK EYE Lot 188

★★★★★
eglbay

Great gun at great price.--Very pleased

Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Shipping Price
★★★★★
Item Description
★★★★★
Seller Fees
★★★★★
Customer Service
★★★★★
Winter Firearm Auction

ROTTWEIL MODEL 72 AAT DOUBLE 32 Lot 234

★★★★★
Stephenroypwr

All good

Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Shipping Price
★★★★★
Item Description
★★★★★
Seller Fees
★★★★★
Customer Service
★★★★★
May 18th, Spring Firearms Auction

RUGER 96 Lot 205

★★★★★
YankeeBidder

When it comes to customer service, Gunslinger is the best. Rifle was damaged in shipment and they bent over backwards to make it right and quickly at that. Will gladly do business with them again. Anyone that gives you customer service that rivals Costco has my business.

Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Shipping Price
★★★★★
Item Description
★★★★★
Seller Fees
★★★★★
Customer Service
★★★★★
New Year Firearm Auction

HIGH STANDARD MODEL DERRINGER Lot 451

★★★★★
mako8551

Accurate description. Amazing team to work with.

Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Shipping Price
★★★★★
Item Description
★★★★★
Seller Fees
★★★★★
Customer Service
★★★★★
September 28, 2019 Fall Firearms Auction

Smith & WESSON MODEL 41 Lot 297

★★★★★
beemaze
Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Item Description
★★★★★
Seller Fees
★★★★★
Customer Service
★★★★★
October 1st, Fall Firearms Auction

JAPANESE ARISAKA TYPE 99 B.A. RIFLE 7.7mm CALIBER 26 BARREL w/ SLING Lot 391

★★★★★
boxer43
Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Shipping Price
★★★★★
Item Description
★★★★★
Seller Fees
★★★★★
April 12th Antiques & Firearms Auction

SAVAGE MODEL 23D BOLT ACTION RIFLE .22 HORNET CAL. w/SCOPE Lot 83

★★★★★
burroughspaul54
Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Shipping Price
★★★★★
Item Description
★★★★★
Seller Fees
★★★★★
Customer Service
★★★★★
February 1st Antiques & Firearms Auction

WINCHESTER 70 Lot 170

★★★★★
DonLudy

I'M VERY HAPPY WITH ALL MY PURCHASES. WILL BE BACK AND PLAN TO BUY MORE. THANK YOU.

Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Shipping Price
★★★★★
Item Description
★★★★★
Seller Fees
★★★★★
Customer Service
★★★★★
Fall Firearm Auction

MILITARY SWORD Lot 43

★★★★★
rondeewill
Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Shipping Price
★★★★★
Item Description
★★★★★
Seller Fees
★★★★★
Customer Service
★★★★★
Fall Firearm Auction

Smith & Wesson Model 59 DA Semi-Automatic Lot 146

★★★★★
Rurak
Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Item Description
★★★★★
Seller Fees
★★★★★
Customer Service
★★★★★
February 5th Fall Firearms Auction

NISCHO MODEL 11 Lot 60

★★★★★
dtmarkey

Great communication, super fast shipping, A+++++

Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Shipping Price
★★★★★
Item Description
★★★★★
Seller Fees
★★★★★
Customer Service
★★★★★
Fall Firearm Auction

REMINGTON MODEL 700 .458 WIN MAG CALIBER BOLT-ACTION RIFLE W/LEUPOLD SCOPE Lot 255A

★★★★★
Claude3

excellent packing and I recived my item quicker than expected would buy from them again

Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Shipping Price
★★★★★
Item Description
★★★★★
Seller Fees
★★★★★
Customer Service
★★★★★
February 17th Firearms, Art, & Jewelry Auction

REMINGTON MODEL 121 Lot 60

★★★★★
Gunsmith1876

Great people to work with

Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Shipping Price
★★★★★
Item Description
★★★★★
Seller Fees
★★★★★
Customer Service
★★★★★
February 5th, 2022 Winter Firearms Auction

JP SAUER & SOHN MODEL 66 Lot 362

★★★★★
DonLudy

great deal

Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Shipping Price
★★★★★
Item Description
★★★★★
Seller Fees
★★★★★
Customer Service
★★★★★
May 21st, 2022 Spring Firearms Auction

SAVAGE MODEL 24 VS Lot 237

★★★★★
arrowset

Good buy

Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Shipping Price
★★★★★
Item Description
★★★★★
Seller Fees
★★★★★
Customer Service
★★★★★
May 18th, Spring Firearms Auction

COLT MODEL 2ND GEN Lot 279

★★★★★
ramonacusick61
Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Shipping Price
★★★★★
Item Description
★★★★★
Seller Fees
★★★★★
Customer Service
★★★★★
February 6th, 2021 Winter Firearms Auction

ITALIAN TERNI CARCANO BOLT ACTION CARBINE 6.5 MM w/FOLDING BAYONET Lot 443

★★★★★
S_j_PEREZ
Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Shipping Price
★★★★★
Item Description
★★★★★
Seller Fees
★★★★★
Customer Service
★★★★★
December 15th 2024 Firearms & Antiques

WINCHESTER MODEL 88 Lot 11

★★★★★
ioway
Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Shipping Price
★★★★★
Item Description
★★★★★
Seller Fees
★★★★★
Customer Service
★★★★★
Spring Firearm Auction

WW II ERA GERMAN WAFFEN MARKED RADOM VIS 35 9MM PISTOL NO MAG Lot 351

★★★★★
rustyhinges202

Nice Item! Fast Shipping! THANKS!

Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Shipping Price
★★★★★
Item Description
★★★★★
Seller Fees
★★★★★
Customer Service
★★★★★
May 19th Firearms, Art & Jewelry Auction

Colt Delta Elite Grips Lot 58

★★★★★
scrounger129

Great to do business with,

Shipping Duration
★★★★★
Shipping Price
★★★★★
Item Description
★★★★★
Seller Fees
★★★★★
Customer Service
★★★★★
August 2017 Gun Accessories Auction